Question:
are there any dangers with turbulence?
Seungyong W
2007-03-10 05:48:53 UTC
on the last flight i have been, there has been extreme turbulence. the flight was literally going down every time there has been turbulence. i was so scared i was having weird thoughts 'was i going to reach home today or not, etc..' is there any potential danger with aircraft turbulence?
Nineteen answers:
lmck
2007-03-13 11:34:09 UTC
Dangerous turbulence is extremely rare. Mostly the only people who get hurt in turbulence are the ones not wearing their seatbelts at the time. Very extreme turbulence can happen unexpectedly but it is very rare.
Chris H
2007-03-10 22:14:32 UTC
Y'all don't keep track of the news do you?



The believe the Adam Air flight KI 574 crash on January 1st 2007 may have been caused by "weather penetration". There were thunder storms in the area at the time and, IIRC, the aircraft had an unserviceable weather radar and was out of contact with ground control.



Modern commercial aircraft are usually able to avoid the worst turbulence, either by climbing above it or diverting around it. They have weather radar or they can be warned off by ground controllers. Some even receive weather radar plots via satellite link (Garmin, for example, do these systems). So it is very unlikely that a commercial aircraft flying in the US would encounter really significant turbulence.



Per passenger mile it is very uncommon to encounter damaging turbulence. But it does happen, usually unexpected clear air turbulence. Typically the injured are the flight attendants and passengers who were too arrogant to wear their seatbelts, like they were told to. Early on in the career of the 777 a United flight attendant told me that they had a much rougher ride in the galley because it was in the tail rather than in the center of the a/c like the 747, they had had a couple of flight attendants break their ankles in turbulence.



I've flown in weather that had the flight attendants confined to their seats for hours. I've looked out of the window of a 747 and seen the wings flexing what looked like twenty feet. People throwing up everywhere. But that's nothing compared to what the a/c can survive. Just a rough flight.



But ultimately aircraft can be lost due to turbulence and wind shear on landing. Even wake turbulence from other aircraft. When I was at RAe Bedford we had a pilot who was still walking with two sticks after surviving a BAe Hawk crash in about 1982 caused by following too close to a Vickers Viscount and rolling the aircraft at low level. He ejected but bounced across the grass because he was too low, the Hawk scraped along the runway on its roof with the photographer still in the front seat, he survived uninjured.
2007-03-12 14:38:33 UTC
Modern commercial aeroplanes can cope with all predictable turbulance. If it seems as though some weather is ahead that it wouldn't like then the weather radar in its nose will inform the crew and they'll go around it.



The aeroplane structure will tolerate considerable turbulance and shrug it off like a bump in the road.



The biggest risk is that unsecured cargo will rattle around the cabin and get damaged. If the cargo is human then it should sit down and wear its seat belt when the warning light is on then it will not get damaged - unless some dingbat has overloaded the overhead locker and something falls out.



You might also vomit.
andy b
2007-03-12 05:19:11 UTC
Turbulence is a bit like sailing on a sea, when it gets rough the ship bobs about, its the same principal in the sky.



Is it dangerous? yes and commercial airlines try to avoid it (its called chop in the industry)



It as far as I am aware has not caused structural failure in an aircraft but if you are not strapped in and you hit a pocket of CAT (Clear air Turbulence) you can find your self on the ceiling of the cabin and then the floor.
sashtou
2007-03-11 17:45:13 UTC
'Yes,' is the short and simple answer. Generally speaking though, No, or Rarely.



There are 'Dangers' in whatever we do ~ skateboarding, bike riding, driving or even flying.



Planes are designed to withstand turbulence's and are very strong. Also, weather radar and reports from other pilots and meteorology in general all helps to make flying much safer.



The greatest danger comes from flying into the stuff while people are 'not strapped into their seats.'



If you can imagine standing still while the lift you are in falls from under you, then you have some idea of what injuries can occur to the human body when it meets the ceiling as it goes the other way ~ travelling rather fast.



It's ALWAYS wise to be belted in (even if loosely so) when seated.



Sash.
2007-03-10 12:55:29 UTC
The biggest danger from turbulence is injuries to the passengers or crew from objects in the cabin. For example if the plane hit bad turbulence and falls several feet anything not properly secured will "Fly in to the air" and collide with anything in its way.
Paul The Rock Ape
2007-03-10 06:19:19 UTC
Only with clear air turbulence (CAT) near the ground. The "going down" feeling you had is more likely to be due to use of the rudder than turbulence.



Commercial pilots don't use the rudder very often (normally only for course correction on take-off or landing or as a means of avoiding turbulence quickly), as it makes the passengers uncomfortable (as you have found out).



Instead, they prefer to use the flaps and ailerons located on either wing, together with an engine power reduction or increase (for minor corrections, engine power only is used), to execute a course change, which is far gentler.



Don't forget, flying is the safest means of travel.



Hope that helps
Blade trio
2007-03-13 01:27:22 UTC
Most planes are made to deal with turbulence, but if the turbulence is in the form of a cyclone or hurricane, the plane might have difficulties. but dont worry, the chances are 1 to a billion.
osvaldo i
2007-03-10 06:03:23 UTC
Yes air planes a designed to out-stand any turbulence remember that the plane fly on top of the clouds and thunder is usually below when the plane is flying, its just a ruff ride but nothing much can really happen.
fast eddie
2007-03-10 06:00:44 UTC
no, none at all, the aircraft keeps in the air by flying through still air infront of it, the still air passes over the wings which are shaped to use this still air to give it lift and stay up. turbulence is when you fly through a piece of air thats not regular, for example after another plane has recently flown through it and disturbed it, or a particulaly large cloud formation which has updraftts and down draughts in it. at this point the air cannot (momentarily) support the planes flight as it flies through it and so the plane starts to literally fall out of the sky, however the moment the plane cuts through normal air, the lift is restored to the wings and normal flight is resumed.
ZUS
2007-03-10 08:28:30 UTC
Light to Moderate turbulence's are normal for the aircraft. But yes severe ones can be dangerous for the aircraft.
ALOPILOT
2007-03-10 07:26:43 UTC
It can be a problem, the wings can become overstressed and crack, the fuselage may bend, there are many potential problems, none of them likely. However, it must be incredibly severe and even then it would be rare to have a crash due to turbulance. If the turbulance is bad enough, the pilots will climb above the weather and just wait until it cools off...
RANDLE W
2007-03-10 17:15:02 UTC
"Extreme" turbulence will tear a control surface off. You did not experience extreme turbulence. You would not be here.
2007-03-10 05:57:48 UTC
air planes or designed to deal with turbulence
predhead33
2007-03-10 11:23:50 UTC
Nailing your head on the roof of the plane, so just an occasional brain damage
310Pilot
2007-03-10 09:49:30 UTC
There can be danger associated with turbulence; however, what you experienced was not at all dangerous (with one exception), just uncomfortable, especially to those who lack understanding of aerodynamics and the physics of flight. The one exception is that there can be some danger to passengers unwise enough to loosen or unfasten their seat belts during flight, as severe turbulence can result in them being "thrown" from their seats and colliding with hard portions of the aircraft structure and/or other passengers, resulting in injuries. I have never understood why passengers almost automatically take off their seat belts when the "seat belt light" goes off (or why the airlines insist on turning that light out after takeoff). Basically, airplanes fly by maintaining a low pressure area over the wing, resulting from the shape of the wing and its movement through the air. Lift varies with angle of attack, meaning the angle of the wing to the air it is moving through. Since air is constantly in motion, the angle of attack (chord line of wing - leading edge to trailing edge) relative to the wind direction (motion of the airplane combined with the direction and speed of the wind, which varies), can result in varying lift forces as the airplane maintains a constant (or near-constant) attitude relative to the ground. Most of these changes in air currents are relatively small, and are not felt in the airplane; however, in areas of stronger changes in air currents (especially over the desert in summer, with alternate columns of rising and descending air, many of which are rather strong), the effective angle of attack of the wing changes frequently and, sometimes, strongly, resulting in rapid changes in the lift vector, resulting in sharp, frequent, but usually short, ascents and descents, i.e.: turbulence. Aircraft are designed to structurally withstand nearly all turbulence, to an extent that you would not believe. The only truly dangerous turbulence is found in and around thunderstorms, which contain up and downdrafts of incredible force, with severe shear between them. Although it is possible to fly through a thunderstorm without losing control of the aircraft (the primary danger there), it is difficult, and structural damage can result from the extreme forces encountered in them. Microbursts, which have caused some crashes on approach and at low-level, are an outflow of the downdrafts from thunderstorms. That is why pilots generally avoid thunderstorms, in addition to the potential for encountering hail or ice in and around them.



Clear Air Turbulence (CAT) is not, technically, a low-level phenomenon. By definition, CAT results from shear between relatively calm air below the jet stream and the much higher speed airflow in the jetstream, which can be extremely intense if the transition between relatively low-speed (and, often, different direction) airflow and the extremely high wind speeds of the jet stream is relatively narrow (say, a few thousand feet). In such instances, the shear and turbulence encountered there (only at hign altitudes) can be severe, possibly leading to a loss of control. That is not to say that turbulence does not occur in clear air at low levels, it does, but it is not termed CAT. Turbulence is not only associated with clouds, but usually results from interaction of wind and terrain, along with heating of the earth. Wind across hills and mountains typically results in waves of turbulence (think of water in a stream flowing over rocks, it is a similar effect) which can extend to quite high altitudes (strong winds over mountains can result in "mountain waves" which have a wave pattern that can extend downwind from the mountains several hundred miles, with both smooth air in the waves and very turbulent air in rotors beneath the crests and above the troughs of the waves). Differential heating of the earth's surface results in rising columns of heated air, which spill over and become nearby descendin columns of air as they cool, often reaching altitudes over 20,000 feet, especially in the deserts. All these factors combine to result in constantly changing wind speed, direction and orientation throughout the air mass.



In summary, I know you had an unpleasant ride, but you really were in no danger. I strongly recommend that you always keep your seat belt fastened when a passenger on an airplane (pilots never take off or loosen their seat belt from before engine start until after shutting down the engines at the destination - there is a good reason for that). Next time you fly and feel some bumps, just remember that the airplane is reminding you that you're flying, not just riding a bus.
2007-03-13 09:49:07 UTC
well it depends how bad it is. if you have NOT got your seatbelts on then you could bash heads in the unlikely state but still it depends how bad it is.







Chris Evans BA Pilot
BonesofaTeacher
2007-03-10 05:56:09 UTC
people have broken bones from it.

that's all i know.
2007-03-10 05:53:47 UTC
NOT REALLY IT DOES HAPPEN SOMETIMES, BUT NOT TO WORRY , SEE YOU DID MAKE IT DIDN'T YOU LOL



THATS ONLY YOU WORRY IF IT DON'T STOP .


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...